Updates, commentary, training and advice on immigration and asylum law

Expert immigration committee left understaffed for over a year


Older content is locked

A great deal of time and effort goes into producing the information on Free Movement, become a member of Free Movement to get unlimited access to all articles, and much, much more


By becoming a member of Free Movement, you not only support the hard-work that goes into maintaining the website, but get access to premium features;

  • Single login for personal use
  • FREE downloads of Free Movement ebooks
  • Access to all Free Movement blog content
  • Access to all our online training materials
  • Access to our busy forums
  • Downloadable CPD certificates

A crack committee of experts charged with advising the government on immigration policy has had an unfilled position for the past 15 months.

The five members of the Migration Advisory Committee – a chair and four other independent economists – provide the Home Office with evidence and advice on migration policy. In October 2016, Sir David Metcalf stepped down as chair and was replaced by one of the four ordinary members, Professor Alan Manning. That left three ordinary members of the committee and one vacancy. The vacancy has been unfilled ever since.

Responsibility for recruiting to the committee lies with the Home Office. There appears to have been no movement on recruiting a replacement for Professor Manning for six months after his elevation. In May 2017, committee minutes noted that

The advert for the recruitment of a new MAC member has to wait until after the elections to be advertised as a result of rules on Purdah.

The position was eventually advertised last summer, with a 16 July deadline for applications. Interviews were due to be completed in September.

The delay since then may reflect the fact that multiple officials, right up to the Home Secretary herself, have input on the recruitment decision. According to the job pack:

The decision to appoint to this role rests with the Home Secretary. Appointable candidates may be invited to meet with her, or another Minister, before a final decision is made. As a result there may be a delay in informing candidates of the outcome of the competition.

The fact that three different people have held the position of immigration minister since last summer will hardly have helped.

Free Movement understands that an “appointable candidate” has now been identified, but at this point their confirmation is being held up by security clearance. This usually takes four to five weeks.

Professor Manning writes in the committee’s annual report, published on Tuesday, that “there remains one appointment on the MAC yet to be filled and we Iook forward to the Government completing the appointment process as swiftly as possible”. The Home Office has confirmed that the process is “ongoing”.

Much of the committee’s work is carried out by a secretariat, with members working two days a months and only getting their hands dirty when major reports are in the offing. The vacancy cannot be said to cripple the organisation. On the other hand, Manning’s predecessor complained that

yet again, the MAC has not received a full work plan for the year 2016-17. There have once again been delays in the appointment of a new Committee member. Both impact on the ability of the Committee to work effectively.

Set up in 2007, the Migration Advisory Committee has established a reputation for high-quality, evidence-based reports and policy advice. Funding and secretariat staff come from the Home Office, but the committee is operationally independent of the department. The committee members are all academic experts in their field.

Home Secretary Amber Rudd has commissioned reports on the politically sensitive issues of immigration from the EU after Brexit and the contribution of international students to the economy. An interim report on EU workers is due out this spring.

Relevant articles chosen for you
Picture of CJ McKinney

CJ McKinney

CJ McKinney is a specialist on immigration law and policy. Formerly the editor of Free Movement, you will find a lot of articles by CJ here on this website! Twitter: @mckinneytweets.